Thieves Guild Vs Dark Brotherhood
→Published on December 3rd, 2014 by divinnyThere are many applications to create funny pictures and fun, one of them is MomentCam. →Published on December 10th, 2014 by divinnyReal Racing is a very cool mobile game for those who want to play racing games on mobile phones. Each launched the latest version always be more exciting. This application is a car racing game where players control a virtual car from behind the wheel. Download aplikasi web design.
This was bugging me and I'd like to know what you think, but nearly everyone I see on the internet thinks the Dark Brotherhood are the evilest guild. In my opinion it's the Thieves Guild for many reasons.1. The Dark Brotherhood do what they do because they have been paid to do so, like any assassin organisation. Whereas the members of the Thieves Guild all put personal gain before anything else in particular.2.
Skyrim: Can I be in the Dark Brotherhood and in the Thieves Guild? Im a rookie to the Skyrim game, but i'm enjoying it A LOT. I just finished the Quest line with the Thieves Guild and was wondering if I can be the leader of both of the guilds or at least a member of both of the guilds without getting in any trouble for being in the other guild. Thieves' Guild. I like the Dark Brotherhood as well, but the Thieves Guild is a huge improvement over Oblivion, and someone worked really hard to come up with different kinds of quests.
Although the Dark Brotherhood don't fight very honorably, just killing the target instantly whilst they are vulnerable, the Thieves Guild simply take everything they own whilst the target isn't looking, destroy their family artifacts and beat them within an inch of their life which seems less honorable to me.3. The Dark Brotherhood abide to a strict set of rules, yes this isn't true for a lot of the beginning of the Dark Brotherhood quest line in Skyrim. The Thieves Guild on the other hand only have one rule: Do not kill the target.4. The Dark Brotherhood support teamwork and helping your fellow assassins. Unlike the Thieves Guild who, similarly in point 1, only help themselves.If you agree/disagree with this please tell me why.
I don't really see what the difference between 'getting payed to commit a crime' and 'stealing money' is or why doing something for the money's sake isn't benefiting the personal gain. Apart from that, most of the jobs you do for Delvin an Vex are jobs the Guild got paid for, much like the DB contracts (only without a ritual). The thief gets his or her share of the profit (your quest-reward) the rest winds up in the treasure-room to which only the Guild's leaders have access to. You are told very early during your career that the Guild doesn't take too kindly to it if you start robbing people who stand under their protection (have the 'protected' Shadowmark on their house) and apparently it is also frowned upon if you pull a big job on your own without sharing the spoils with your guildmates, the Guild has even marked escape-routes out of some of the prisons should you ever be unfortunate enough to end up there.
So I would say, they do take care of their own as well as support teamwork. The big difference between both groups (apart from the obvious killing and not killing thing) seems to be for me, that most of the TG consider their thieving as a job in which they take great pride, while the DB seems to come close to a secret religious order at times.Apart from that I wouldn't agree that the DB always kill their targets quickly. They seem to take a great deal of pleasure in cruelty, physical or otherwise. But that is probably too much of a spoiler to discuss here any further. This said, whether you consider stealing a candlestick a worse crime than killing somebody, ending their lives and bringing misery to their friends and family, might depend on personal moral values.edited for typos and grammar issuesEdited by Anska, 21 March 2013 - 02:59 PM. Thug's Guild is more like it. I really hate them in Skyrim compared to the Robin Hood guild you saw in Cyodiil.
In Oblivion you were kinda like the misunderstood good guy on the wrong side of the law whereas in Skyrim you're a selfish thug improving your lot in life by trampling over others purely for your own benefit.The DB on the other hand.well they're the DB. Assassins/murderers for hire.
So long as you pay, the target dies so it's all about simply fulfilling a contract. I would still consider them more morally detestable (even though I love the DB questline in both games) because I consider murder a greater crime than theft. But at least they are professional about it. In Oblivion they had a decent code to follow as well although it's little more than a novelty in Skyrim.Edited by Kayyyleb, 21 March 2013 - 04:17 PM. Well, if I'm playing a 'good' character who needs to join the thieves guild, I compensate from the things I take by leaving something at least as valuable in its place.
Impossible to do the same with the DB.The idea that killing for contract is somehow honorable.How is it honorable to take money to end someone's life, just because someone coughed up the cash and is unwilling to do the murder themselves? And how is taking money for murder not just as greedy (or more so) than taking valuables for money?. Well, if I'm playing a 'good' character who needs to join the thieves guild, I compensate from the things I take by leaving something at least as valuable in its place. Impossible to do the same with the DB.The idea that killing for contract is somehow honorable.How is it honorable to take money to end someone's life, just because someone coughed up the cash and is unwilling to do the murder themselves? And how is taking money for murder not just as greedy (or more so) than taking valuables for money?Nobody said it was honourable.
Thieves Guild Or Dark Brotherhood Armor
Killing in general isn't honorable by my standards so the Companions come across as little more than overly self-righteous mercenaries. Well, if I'm playing a 'good' character who needs to join the thieves guild, I compensate from the things I take by leaving something at least as valuable in its place. Impossible to do the same with the DB.The idea that killing for contract is somehow honorable.How is it honorable to take money to end someone's life, just because someone coughed up the cash and is unwilling to do the murder themselves? And how is taking money for murder not just as greedy (or more so) than taking valuables for money?Nobody said it was honourable. Killing in general isn't honorable by my standards so the Companions come across as little more than overly self-righteous mercenaries.Actually, the OP did: (and that was who I was responding to)2.
Thieves Guild Vs Dark Brotherhood Dlc
Although the Dark Brotherhood don't fight very honorably, just killing the target instantly whilst they are vulnerable, the Thieves Guild simply take everything they own whilst the target isn't looking, destroy their family artifacts and beat them within an inch of their life which seems less honorable to me. Yeah, the Thieves Guild aren't 'good' by any means, but they're certainly not evil.
That one rule they have says it all: they respect, above all else, that they cannot 'steal' the life of another person. If anything, it just shows that the Thieves Guild doesn't respect the ownership of property, and that they're willing to beat the hell out of their targets to get it - since Skyrim's a warrior culture and not one for sneaking around, that 'thug' lifestyle's natural, but it still separates them from the bandits, the Forsworn, and most notably, the Dark Brotherhood. They're anti-heroes, but certainly not worshippers of Sithis, murderers, and torturers.